Cantafio's Buckhorn Supper Club

Charming staff, GREAT food, lots of options. Everything was delicious from the prawns to the steak to the roast duck. Yes,I tried everything from my fellow diners plates. We will return and select something different from the menu. Make sure to try the old fashions.

Cantafio’s Buckhorn is hands down my favorite dining spot near Beaver Dam, offering an exceptional experience from start to finish. The service here is consistently top-notch—friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu, ensuring you feel right at home. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, with a homey charm that makes it perfect for a relaxed yet indulgent meal. The rustic yet refined decor complements the warmth of the staff, creating an atmosphere where you can truly unwind. The NY Strip is an absolute standout. Cooked to perfection, each bite was tender and flavorful, proving that they know exactly how to treat a good cut of meat. The scallops were equally impressive—plump, perfectly fried, and dipped in butter to enhance their natural sweetness. The portion size of the scallops were generous, Cantafio’s Buckhorn strikes a perfect balance between comfort and quality, making it a must-visit for anyone in the area.

Hands down the BEST eatery in Beaver Dam! The service was simply outstanding. Very warm, welcoming and friendly and you never had an empty drink on your table. Even more, the food was phenomenal. The Buckhorn Tradition - a deep fried onion with chipotle sauce, was huge! The steak was perfectly cooked and hit the spot, too. Altogether, everything was fresh and hot. One of my favorite aspects, however, was the beautiful homage to the owners fallen veteran son. Bringing his story into their restaurant provided a touching aspect to my visit. Kudos to the owners for providing free meals to veterans, too. The owners, along with the staff, truly put their heart and soul into this steakhouse. It is immaculately clean and provides a wonderful atmosphere for a dinner out. My husband and I would happily make the drive from Appleton to return. Highly, highly recommend - it's worth the stop!

Have been going here for quite some time. The food is always good and the people and atmosphere always fun. Order an ice cream after dinner drink...you won't get one any better than here. The absolute best. My tuna steak is always cooked to perfection. Thanks Joe and Bobbi!!

This has been the absolute best restaurant I have ever went to. The staff was so friendly the tables were put together so nicely there was nothing stand or looked disgusting anyway. It honestly looked as if everything was bought that day and laid out that night that's how well put together and clean the slocked. Such a great experience in food was amazing I love the persona of the place and the discounts are actually pretty nice my husband's a veteran we got a 10% off discount and at the end of the night my children actually were able to pick out a free toy. We ended up buying an appetizer, two 27 16 oz steaks plus 2 kids meals and on top of that I got a margherita and my husband got a beer and to go we got to deserts and 2 separate meals for lunch tomorrow and it honestly only came out to 106. And if you go to restaurant and you're ordering that might typically it does come out to a little bit more expensive but so nice I love it There and we're going again tonight I can't wait. Best experience ever and if I can suggest going anywhere to specifically a steak place or any type of restaurant expresly with your kids go here best place ever next time I'm going I'm tipping everybody a 20 tip that is how great the staff and the experience was for me I love it so much.

Had the Big Ben prime rib with baked potatoes and onions block appetizer. Was seated right away and then server took my drink order. She was very pleasant and professional. The food was very tasty. I also received a bread stick basket with cheese spread and a roll. The roll wasl the only thing that did not stand out. Also had the clam chowder.

First time trying, we've passed by since moving nearby and have wanted to try it for a long time and I must say....Exceeded all expectations! We started with mozzarella sticks for our appetizer (ate them before I got a picture) definitely was like a homemade marinara which was very good, very flavorful! I ordered the ny strip with a baked potato, which was the most perfect baked potato I've ever had hands down soft all the way through, the steak I ordered medium rare and it was perfect just the way I like it. Also got a side of scallops, broiled, which were pretty perfect too. Husband got a medium rare rib eye with potato wedges and that was cooked perfect to his liking. Service was great and food came out in a timely manner, we were well taken care of! 100% we will be back for more!!

This was our first time here. It is a traditional supper club. The food was good the service was great day the ice cream drinks were good. You get alot of food for a fair price. In Milwaukee you would pay 75.00 or more for the prime rib that was 36.00 here.